(Sigh...) Yeah, after their debut (which aside from the two tracks with vocals was pure bliss), I think they got confused about whether they wanted to be the artsy jazz/funk band they started out as or have some commercial success. Maybe they got pressure from the record label; I don't know, but on the second and third albums (Back to Back and Don't Stop the Music), it seems like they were trying to have it both ways. Both of those albums had an increased amount of questionable vocal tunes and even an instrumental or two that veered a little too close to smooth jazz. There are some gems on both where they got back to their original vision, but there was more crap to wade through. Their 4th, "Heavy Metal Bebop" was a great live album with only one vocal tune (also the only studio track), but most of the material was from the previous studio albums.
On their 5th album, "Détente," it was back to that mixed bag of lame vocal tracks and some cool instrumental ones. Finally, on their 6th album, "Straphangin'," they returned to form and made another artsy jazz/funk album that was devoid of any vocal tracks; not quite as ambitious as their debut, but a very nice album nonetheless. Then they disbanded until 1990, when they made two more albums. Those were on a different record label, which explains why they aren't in this boxset. There's some real nice stuff on both, but imho, they never quite lived up to the promise of their debut, which I consider to be a stone cold classic.
So... you guys are lucky you got the set for a great price. I'd say that between "Back to Back," "Don't Stop the Music" and "Détente," you could probably make yourself one CD-R of worthwhile stuff.
BTW, Michael Brecker made 8 albums as a leader. There's not a commercial track to be found on any of them and I love them all! But you'd have to be a fan of straight-ahead jazz to appreciate them, with the exception of "Now You See it, Now You Don't" and some of "Don't Try This at Home," which have some funk and fusion elements.
Bookmarks