Personally, I thought Doyle Bramhall II sounded fantastic with Waters. Given the fact that Gilmour has a very bluesy tone to his playing to begin with, I thought Doyle fit in just perfectly, and I liked his vintage guitar tones a lot better than Gilmour's high tech, 80's, EMG pickup and refrigerator sized effects rack driven tone, as heard on the Delicate Sound Of Thunder and Pulse live albums. That 80's sound worked for the newer material, but somehow, I kept wishing to hear Money, Comfortably Numb being played with passive pickups (like he used up until the mid 80's, and began using again in the 21st century when he started playing his black Strat again) and just a few pedals.
Bookmarks