Stevo, I have often been in the position you are in and I truly enjoy it. There is so much great stuff out there that so much of the enjoyment it actually finding it.
I am 49 and grew up with most of the "classic" bands, so it has been the Neo Prog, Post Prog and any other newer prog groups that I have had to explore.
I don't like ITunes and the such. I like to support groups by purchasing brick and mortar cd's whenever possible and do my homework with the goal being the finding of new genres/groups and delving into their cd's. I use ITunes to load songs from CD's I own onto an MP3 player, but I have never downloaded a song from any on line service.
It is difficult to suggest possibilities without knowing what you have liked from your earlier meanderings. However, I suggest that you just keep open to all the ways of finding out about new bands. I explore groups I encounter in magazines like Prog and Progression. I check out the "CD Reviews" section of DPRP for groups I haven't heard yet. I find a group I enjoy and find someone similar (but different) and start exploring.
I typically like the classic prog sound and most of the neo prog groups. I like some of the Post Prog I have heard, but recently I stumbled on Anathema. Was not at all familiar with them, and stumbled on a used copy of one of their CD's at Newbury Comics. Purchased it and LOVED it. Stumbled on another one of theirs at Newbury's on another visit and now have moved all their releases up on my list.
Just remember, so much of the enjoyment it the trip you took to get there.
Bookmarks