I flat-out, unabashedly love this album. I've said many times that it was my "gateway" to prog and I still love to listen to it. One of my all-time faves.
But there's absolutely nothing groundbreaking about it.
I flat-out, unabashedly love this album. I've said many times that it was my "gateway" to prog and I still love to listen to it. One of my all-time faves.
But there's absolutely nothing groundbreaking about it.
Music isn't about chops, or even about talent - it's about sound and the way that sound communicates to people. Mike Keneally
This is close to my own position. When I discovered Asia, I was a very young teen and had not heard anything remotely like "prog." Among the other pop/rock songs I was hearing on the radio, Asia immediately stood out from the bands everyone is comparing them to (Journey, etc.). Songs like "Only Time Will Tell" and "The Smile Has Left Your Eyes" had a very European elegance to them (that I now can see as going back a bit to the "baroque pop" sound of the mid-to-late '60s) that was simply not present (at least to anywhere near the same degree) in the other AOR acts of the time. I loved it then (especially Alpha, which I still prefer to the debut), though I certainly grew to prefer the classic prog sound of their predecessor bands once I heard it. I can totally see why fans of the earlier groups would have hated it--in some ways, it probably was aimed at younger listeners like myself. However, I think people sometimes downplay the unique aspects of their songs and especially arrangements, which were very apparent to those still unfamiliar with classic prog, and who could only compare Asia to the other commercial AOR groups dominating the radio and MTV at the time.
It's shite.
The off-the-charts instrumentation in KC's ITCOTCK is well above that of The Moody Blues & The Beatles. Really, YES 90125 is perhaps more groundbreaking than that ASIA album. Or how about Genesis Abacab, released the same year? ASIA was just an attempt to sound like bands that were already really selling very well at the time, and they pulled it off! For one album at least. Their goal was not to re-invent the wheel, but roll with it.
At least it beats the shit out of Rush. Much better melodies. Heat of the Moment is the worst track.
One of my Desert Island Discs, actually. I was 8 when it came out and hadn't been introduced to the likes of Yes, KC, Genesis, etc., so this was my first semi-proggish record. The sound of it takes me back to the time when I was first discovering what kind of music really spoke to me, so it will always hold up for me. I can see why it might not for others, though.
Progtopia is a podcast devoted to interviewing progressive rock, metal, and electronic artists from the past and present, featuring their songs and exclusive interviews. Artists interviewed on the show have included Steve Hackett, Sound of Contact, Larry Fast, Circus Maximus, Anubis Gate, Spock's Beard, and many more. http://progtopia.podomatic.com See you in a land called Progtopia!
I always thought Kansas did this.
This is what I think set them apart from their AOR peers. At least, on the debut - they lost that going forward, which is why the debut is by far their best effort, IMO.
No, not really.
Music isn't about chops, or even about talent - it's about sound and the way that sound communicates to people. Mike Keneally
King crimson who put out a couple albums around this time and the Talking heads stuff was way more interesting to my ears
The debut Asia album( to me) only had a couple above average songs....no classics or epics that demand the kind of attention it gets...all fluff and no guts....
I thought that Brian Lane and Steve Howe were responsible in forming Asia? Didn't John Wetton help, too? I actually like Asia. They blended the new wave of The Buggles with the bombastic prog of Yes and ELP. I think some of Geoff's keyboard lines are like a cross between Rick Wakeman and Keith Emerson. I have watched the Asia In Asia concert a few times on YouTube, and I think some of the songs from the debut come off better live, especially when Geoff inserts his mini-moog into Heat Of The Moment and Only Time Will Tell. Also, nice to see that he was using an actual organ onstage, instead of just synths. Getting back on track, I do think that Asia was very groundbreaking. Along with Drama by Yes, World's Apart by Saga, and Abacab by Genesis, Asia mixed prog, new wave, and arena rock. I think that Songs From The Lion's Cage by Arena sounds like a mix of Asia and Marillion. I also hear some Asia influence in Enchant.
GOTCHA! That was awesome! Love those guitar parts!
I didn't know this tour was taped. Thanks for sharing. Gotta go search it out.
Now this was an example of a classic 1970s band not being satisfied with the same-old same-old, reinventing themselves with fresh sounding music that didn't sound like god-awful corporate, back-room Brian Lane-brain induced AOR.
*Dragon Attack* was kinda the foreshadowing of *Hot Space*. *Hot Space* kind of ruining their career in the US until Bill and Ted brought them back to cultural relevance.
Still waiting for the Queen catalogue to be re-issued in 5.1.
The live "Staying Power" is WAY, WAY, WAY, WAY better than the studio version. I wish they'd put the cheap funk crap back and done THIS version in the studio.
The Milton Keynes show was shot and aired on the BBC and MTV. I actually remember staying up and watching the MTV broadcast (though I think I fell asleep after only a few songs...hey, I was 9 years old, I wasn't used to staying up past 9:00!) The concert was released on DVD a few years ago, under that rather unfortunate title Queen On Fire At The Bowl. Great, great show.
Well, I think it helped that Queen always evolved and did different types of things on each album. One might be forgiven if they thought A Night At The Opera or News Of The World were various artist compilations (except that obviously, there's one guy singing lead on most of the songs). And the various band members all had different interests that came to the fore in the songwriting. So the idea of moving in a different direction in the 80's was just their SOP. Now, it may have cost them some of their Stateside audience, but hey, that's what happens sometimes? They were still huge everywhere else in the world.
That and Another One Bites The Dust. Roger Taylor suggests that they were "sidetracked by the success of Another Bites The Dust down a road that wasn't really Queen music".
Oy! Don't remind me! Mike Myers was right when he said "We've just whizzed on a Picasso" after watching the "Wayne's World" version of the Bohemian Rhapsody video. To make matters worse, that was just after Freddie passed (which I think also had something to do with Queen coming back to prominence, Stateside), so they inserted all these extra shots of Freddie from newsreel footage and such, so the video came off as "We're paying tribute to Freddie, but we're also trying to promote our tacky little movie at the same time". Should have been one or the other, if you ask me.
This album was so disappointing to me it turned me off from buying albums for a while. I was so psyched for the the first prog supergroup. Growing up with ELP, YES et al this just had to be prog of all time - until it came out and was a bubble gum prog like.
In my opinion only
Sorry to sound like a music snob, but to call Asia "musically groundbreaking" is a bunch of shite. Not including the world of classical, electronic, jazz, prog alone way before and after makes this album look like a cheaply made chinese plastic toy.
"Improvisation is not an excuse for musical laziness" - Fred Frith
"[...] things that we never dreamed of doing in Crimson or in any band that I've been in," - Tony Levin speaking of SGM
Bookmarks