You'd think that they'd change it up a little. Let's see.
Neil
You'd think that they'd change it up a little. Let's see.
Neil
I agree and for that reason, can't justify going. What are the chances of Genesis doing a full Suppers Ready? Or a full One for the Vine? Hell, I'd be happy to hear Dodo or The Lady Lies. So many great tracks that will likely get overlooked for Invisible Touch and We Can't Dance. I could understand that when those albums were current or within a decade of release, but it's not like they are that highly regarded anymore. Those albums are *really* old now. Are there really that many 50+ aged soccer grandmas looking forward to Throwing it All Away??
I'm just hoping for 20-30 minutes of 70s Genesis.
What can this strange device be? When I touch it, it brings forth a sound (2112)
If it's something like this then it would be in the ballpark: https://www.setlist.fm/stats/average...?tour=6bd6faa6
I don't think I'd recommend Phil try to do "Mama" at this point.
I don't know. If I still lived in the Philly area, I'd go. I live in Dallas now, so if they play in Dallas or even Austin or Houston I'd go.
Some history from the Philly area where I attended all tours from 74-84 before leaving the area. Two shows at the Tower in March of 74, about 6K+ total in attendance. Lamb at the Civic Center in Dec 74, about the same, maybe a bit less. April 76, two shows same night at the Tower, again about 6K+. March 77 W&W tour, now at the Spectrum, according to the review in the paper, 16K there. By Duke multiple sell-out nights at the Spectrum.
I wonder what a similar analysis from NY, Chicago, Cleveland, Detroit, Boston, etc. would yield?
So....if maybe 15K show up for this tour's Philly show, how many would be disappointed if say 3/4's of the set is Duke and before stuff? Maybe not that many.........
Put another way. Take something akin to the 2007 set-list, Replace Hold on My Heart, Throwing it All Away, and Follow You Follow Me with older classic stuff, maybe another medley, and you'd have something really good.
I think the 2007 setlist was fairly well balanced, although of course I would like more 70s material in an ideal world.
Realistically, I expect them to keep the same kind of setlist and change a few things. Maybe a different medley, probably something else than "Ripples".
(I can't help but notice that Nic Collins said that he spent time learning some complex songs that finally aren't in the setlist, so I won't hold high expectations for the proggy stuff...)
Last edited by Interstellar; 05-02-2021 at 05:08 AM.
For other setlist speculation it's probably good to look at setlists since 1980 or so. For example they had rehearsed One for the Vine, which I think has now been dropped, but it was played on the 1980 tour.
I'm sure this new medley will be a crowd pleaser.
The Serpent / Never A Time / The Waiting Room / Papa He Said / Harold The Barrel / Me and Virgil
Throwing it is over 30 years old and probably repeated more than Suppers Ready has ever been. Intelligent people who appreciate music, including students at Rock School will appreciate Suppers ready more than that pop 80s/90s BS. Suppers Ready is far more goth and if folks saw the new 4k restore of the Paris performance, they would appreciate it more.
I'm sick of that medley, it's been done to death. Here's what my sources tell me the setlist is (and it's very reliable) :
-------------------------------------
Intro tape/walk-on: Easy Lover (New version with Phil rapping every other word)
Window
Ravine
Naminanu (Hackett guesting on nylon guitar)
It's Gonna Get Better (Banks doing 'I Can't Dance' walk through the audience)
Build Me A Mountain
Question medley: Who Dunnit? / Am I Very Wrong? / Wot Gorilla? / Do You Know, Do You Care?
Banjo Man
Mike & The Mechanics medley (Hackett guesting on nylon guitar)
Hair On The Arms And Legs (extended 12" dance remix version)
In Too Deep / Hogweed closing section
Medley: Throwing It All Away ("eee-ba-day-ee-ayy" live intro only) / Phil's "Other world" story / Enter Sandman / Dusk / "Eee-ba-day-ee-ayy' reprise
Air drum duet
Against All Odds (Banks 'I Can't Dance' walk reprise)
Vancouver (Phil in flower mask)
-------------------------------------
Encore:
-------------------------------------
The Jackson Tapes
Congo (Stuermer lead vocal)
Congo again
... a few obvious choices there, but Window is always a crowd pleaser of an opener, and Vancouver to end the set is a powerhouse as well. Some oddball choices too, I definitely didn't expect them to resurrect In Too Deep. Rumour has it that cities with no live show curfew will be treated to a third version of Congo.
Last edited by Progatron; 05-02-2021 at 04:33 PM.
Interviewer of reprobate ne'er-do-well musicians of the long-haired rock n' roll persuasion at: www.velvetthunder.co.uk and former scribe at Classic Rock Society. Only vaguely aware of anything other than music.
*** Join me in the Garden of Delights for 3 hours of tune-spinning... every Saturday at 5pm EST on Deep Nuggets radio! www.deepnuggets.com ***
I have it on good authority that 'Wooden Mask' will be in the set-list on some shows. And Nic Collins might even do that 'clock' thing with his hands that his father did in the 'Anything She Does' video.
Sent from my iPhone using Tapatalk Pro
I didn't include that because they're not 100% on it. Word is they are split down the middle on whether to play that or Pennsylvania Flickhouse. Apparently when that was suggested, Mike stormed out of the room but quickly returned when he remembered that it wasn't one of Tony's pieces.
Interviewer of reprobate ne'er-do-well musicians of the long-haired rock n' roll persuasion at: www.velvetthunder.co.uk and former scribe at Classic Rock Society. Only vaguely aware of anything other than music.
*** Join me in the Garden of Delights for 3 hours of tune-spinning... every Saturday at 5pm EST on Deep Nuggets radio! www.deepnuggets.com ***
^ A song by Anthony Phillips' pre-Genesis group. Was put out on CD by a Genesis fan club.
Bookmarks