I understand. When it comes to Transatlantic, it was actually The Whirlwind that I liked the most. I've come to appreciate the first two more since then, but Whirlwind is still my favorite -- musically it's more interesting to me, for some reason. I'm curious to see how this new one sounds in relation to the others once it comes out.
I am of the same view as you, relative to The Whirlwind. I know it's generally not that popular here on PE, but to me it brings out all the things that I like about the musicians' work. The disc-long epic, which blows me away (excuse the pun), and then some nice original and cover tracks on the Bonus Disc. I am especially drawn to "Spinning" and "Lending A Hand" and also like the "Hogweed" and "Soul Sacrifice" tracks a lot. Stolt, Portnoy, Trewavasa and Morse - what a juggernaut line up and quite a magnificent release.
As to the new release, I will eventually purchase the extended version CD's and am looking forward to listening to them in depth.
Sounds good! Got my order in at Ken's! Come quickly, Feb.5!!
"Moustache stays right where it's at" - Clutch
Great song, it gives a good preview of the new TA album. I'm in.
I can say that of the very few good things caused by covid, this can be one of them. On how these musicians normally go about their professional lives, it takes a span of 4-5 years to write, record and promote a new TA album.
Sadly, the touring part is as frozen as the covid vaccines will be while shipped to the world.
Not only the vocals are great but so the arrangements are as well. This 9 minute track is so good it felt like a 3 minute short track, the lyrics are also very "covid" influenced about the lockdowns and isolation but again, it is a motivator to expand their creative juices and share with the fans.
Also added to my LE wish list, can't wait.
Transatlantic makes life a little bit better...
Prog's Not Dead
Calyx (Canterbury Scene) - http://www.calyx-canterbury.fr
Legends In Their Own Lunchtime (blog) - https://canterburyscene.wordpress.com/
My latest books : "Yes" (2017) - https://lemotetlereste.com/musiques/yes/ + "L'Ecole de Canterbury" (2016) - http://lemotetlereste.com/musiques/lecoledecanterbury/ + "King Crimson" (2012/updated 2018) - http://lemotetlereste.com/musiques/kingcrimson/
Canterbury & prog interviews - https://www.youtube.com/channel/UCdf...IUPxUMA/videos
WOW!!! and a good video to boot.... One could say almost epic... Expectations surpassed...
Count me in as another fan of The Whirlwind. This time they might even have surpassed that very album. Just wow![]()
i'm hoping with the new release, that the first two will be re-issued. Kalidoscope was my introduction and i didn't like it, but they redeemed themselves with Whirlwind. eventually i'll get the first 2.
^^ Wasn't Whirlwind before Kaleidoscope?
Whirlwind and Kaleidoscope were OK, but what I really like now are the live performances. The Kaleidoscope show at the Keswick kicked ass![]()
On the verge of indecision
I'll always take the roundabout way
I ustabee smart when I was young, oh well. In 2010 on the evening of my father's death TA played NYC, I went with my prog-loving son David, we talked about whether going was appropriate and decided my dad would have wanted us to, off we went. As the intro to Rose Colored Glasses began (about the death of Neal's father) Neal leaned into the mic and said "This is for Barry." My son and I looked at each other and our eyes welled up with tears, it's still on Youtube a decade later and my eyes still well up, a never to be forgotten moment. Thanks, Martin.
Last edited by BarryLI; 11-27-2020 at 01:06 PM.
That's a great anecdote, Barry. What an emotional moment that would have been for you, and, ten years late, I'm sure still is. Thanks for sharing.
Quite a Thanksgiving story and my father travelled the Bridge Across Forever in Nov 2007.
On the verge of indecision
I'll always take the roundabout way
I was at that show too, Barry. Great story.
I saw them when they toured for the first album, at Wetlands in NYC. That was a small club, and I was like 6 feet from the stage so that was really good. I'd seen all the band members live before, except for Portnoy, so that was a good show. I'm a casual Dream Theater fan (only saw them once), so not really interested in debating with anyone if Portnoy is shizznit or shizznot, but I really enjoy his enthusiasm, and it was fun to see his "show" up front. Actually, I'd met Portnoy twice before then hanging out after a Marillion show (AoS tour) and backstage when Echolyn played at Wetlands.
I've seen Flower Kings a number of times, and once was at The Bottom Line (forget which tour), the night before I was laid off from my job. I somehow knew my number was up, because they were axing about half the staff (about 1000 people), but somehow I was very relaxed because of that, and FK are so relaxing (this was seated, again very close to the stage), with their glittery outfits reflecting the lights, that I somehow had the mellowest feeling, and had all the patience in the world as they played, I think, all of Flower Power, or at least a good amount of it. They released an official bootleg of the show on CD, so that's a nice memento of that weirdly enjoyable show.
BTW, if you reread BravadoNJ's post, I THINK he was saying Kaleidoscope was the album that he HEARD first, not that it was released before Whirlwind.
I rejoined Neal's Inner Circle membership earlier this year and this months release was great for Transatlantic fans. A DVD of the one time show with the 6 man Transatlantic and also a CD from their first tour (might be of interest to JKL2000 above as it must be the show you mentioned!) I'll let Neal explain:
IC is download only now but the files include artwork for CD/DVD tray, cover and disc. I've listened to the Wetlands CD, same setlist as Live in America disc with the addition mentioned of Back in NYC. It is a good quality boot, some audience chatter is audible at some quiet moments. I've been pretty happy with the IC releases since i rejoined. I do wish there was a premium option to receive a physical copy instead of having to create my own though.So, I decided I wanted to do a Transatlantic Inner Circle release this month but then realized we’ve done all of the demos... and we’ve done the live albums... so what could we possibly do?!
That was when I found the video from the Sweden Rock festival from 2014 which is well-filmed but the audio is a bit overloaded. We’ve done the best we can to fix it up, and hopefully you’ll enjoy this one. Transatlantic have only very rarely played festival shows, and this was also the first time we had played in Sweden. That gave us the bonus of having Daniel Gildenlow join us on stage to sing his vocal part from "Into The Blue," and well... he stayed on stage for the rest of the show, joining Ted Leonard who was our fifth member for that tour! Oh, and then it started to rain! Always a risk with outdoor shows, but we carried on! Hopefully the audio shortcomings won’t stop you from enjoying a unique show in our career.
The other thing I was considering sharing this month was an audience recording from our very first Transatlantic tour, which someone had shared with me. It’s a bootleg, but because this was a small club, the performance is very clear. Then I thought, why I don’t I just give you them both! Given that it was our first tour, the setlist has some Beatles covers, some Genesis covers (including the only attempt at "Back in NYC," given we were in NYC… you’ll hear why we never tried it again!) plus the closing medley, where we play songs from our current/ past bands.
I hope you enjoy these and that they whet your appetite for what we have lined up with The Absolute Universe!
CD Wetlands Preserve Cover Nov 2020 copy.jpg
IC Cover Nov 2020 copy.jpg
Bookmarks