Yes, nice to see them enjoying themselves, but, by God, Phil looks old and weak. Whilst his voice didn't sound all that bad on that clip, he suffers from the problem of most older singers, in that the high notes are difficult to do, so he doesn't do them, and he quite clearly would be incapable of performing tracks such as Dodo/Lurker, Musical Box, and the Duke's End stuff, simply because of the energy required for such performances, which sadly seem beyond him in that state.
Let's leave great memories of a great band and performer where they belong - in our memories and hearts. A Genesis reunion would be a travesty now.
Bookmarks