Fish: Farewell to Childhood vs Return to Childhood

[progfan915]

Any thoughts? I have the Return DVD which I thought was just OK; the vocals were really strained. How does Farewell compare? I have pretty much everything else Fish has put out. Should I get this one too?

thanks!

[ytserush]

Any thoughts? I have the Return DVD which I thought was just OK; the vocals were really strained. How does Farewell compare? I have pretty much everything else Fish has put out. Should I get this one too?

thanks!

I have Return as well. I plan on getting Farewell at some point, but I can't see myself being all that impressed with it. For Return, I'm more likely to throw on the disc with the solo stuff more than the Return portion. I realize that there were preparation problems with rehearsals or lack there of if I recall correctly, but it's a rough listen for me. It's possible Farewell might be better on that front, but I dpn't have it yet for comparison.