I think they were amazingly consistent from Tresspass Through Duke and Duke is my favourite Genesis album. Oddly the one I can't get on with is W&W, much prefer Trick and ATTWT which bookended it. I'm not sure why I've never got on with it, all the components are there.
Duke is just perfect though. I think they got a bit inconsistent afterwards although I love certain tracks. Domino is a belter, Fading Lights too. And yes, all the later stuff was far more powerful live.
Bookmarks