Given your enthusiasm, I gave Jubal a try. Mostly because Ernest Borgnine and Rod Steiger were in it because, as you may remember, I'm not a fan of Glenn Ford.
First off, I gotta say that I love that Technicolor look, especially in the early days with its saturation of color. This movie was a little toned down compared to some I've seen but the opening titles were beautiful.
Rod Steiger as Pinky. Huh. I've seen Steiger do an excellent job in movies but I've also noticed he sometimes goes over the top and I thought he did in this movie, too. Noah Beery, Jr was great, tho, in a smaller part. I was surprised to see Emile Meyer in a small supporting part (Meyer also played the villainous cattle baron Ryker in Shane).
The other thing that surprised me was that I thought Ford was very good in it. In fact, I thought he was better than Steiger in this movie. I doubt this movie will change my mind about Ford but I'm going to try to keep an open mind from now on where he's concerned.
I thought Ernie Borgnine as Shep was excellent. It's too bad that when I think of Ernie, the first things that pop to mind are McHale's Navy and The Poseidon Adventure, which is unfair because I think of those as lightweight roles. I guess I need to keep reminding myself of what a truly great actor he could be when I look at his filmography and remember him in From Here to Eternity, Marty, and The Wild Bunch. Some other movies I've seen him in where he did an admirable job are Bad Day at Black Rock, The Flight of the Phoenix, The Dirty Dozen, Emperor of the North Pole (very much like his sadistic Sgt "Fatso"), and Escape from New York. I've seen him in other things and I think he's at his best when the director keeps him reigned in.
SPOILERS FOLLOW
As for the story itself, which is based on Othello, I only have two things to say. The first regards the death of Mae, Shep's wife. In Othello, Othello strangles his wife Desdemona because he thinks she's betrayed him. In Jubal, however, it's Pinky who beats Mae because she's rejected him. I don't condone violence against women, in fiction or reality, but I thought Shep was more than justified had he slapped the shit out of her. But this leads to my second criticism:
So, Pinky beats the crap out of her to the extent she dies at the end of the movie. I could see where the writers were going with that story line and I thought it would make for a very interesting ending but they didn't follow through. The screenplay had two writers. Now whether they worked together or separately on it, I don't know, but I think the ending got changed. Maybe it was the director who changed it. Who knows? I can't even begin to speculate why, but it made for an ending that was way too quick and I thought it sucked. In fact, it kinda ruined the movie.
Bookmarks