Do you ever go and see the bands live in concert, because the "snap-shot" will never be re-produced?
I don't have 5.1/surround, so my perspective on the re-mixes is purely as a stereo-listener. I personally welcome the re-mixes (be they SW, JJ or anyone else), because I like to hear the re-interpretation of that recording session, which will always be different in some way to the original snapshot. I may hear a deeper sound-stage, sweeter trebles, fuller bass, and all sorts of better (or different) sounding instruments. The original "snap-shot" is never lost, so it remains preserved in aspic for those who prefer that outlook on the recording, whereas the rest of us explore the possibilities of the new longer-form digital releases and hi-res possibilities.
There have been numerous re-mixes over many years (the first I came across was The Associates - The Affectionate Punch, which was back in the vinyl days) where bands and artists have changed the sound with small tweaks and/or major re-working), so it's not just the modern way. Some re-mixes have been train-wrecks, and I'm sure you all could cite your best known.
Back to the OP. I'm a long time fan of King Crimson (Salford double-header is just weeks away, whooppee!) and 70's Yes, so I've been well and truly skinned in the last few years, but without exception (if you'll excuse KC filling the excellent value boxed sets with irrelevant stocking-filler audience bootlegs) I've been very happy with the new "deluxe" releases. I have the original "snap-shot" presented in hi-res and the new, (in most cases) preferred re-mix, plus all the hit-or-miss bonus material, which would be dependent upon your preference of live music, out-takes, demos, etc.
This is a forum for opinions, but you will see on this thread that many believe they hold opinions for everyone else. The simple question from the OP will solicit multiple opinions. Some of us will feel ripped-off by the "deluxe" format. Some of will revel in it. Some of will fit somewhere in between. I know I've been largely pleased to date, but I'm aware that some releases, from bands I do not care for, have been less well-received.
Those who have had their fingers burnt will stop buying them. Others will buy them until their enthusiasm withers. As an economics graduate, I know that as long as consumer demand pays the way for producer supply they will continue to find a way to the market.
Bookmarks